Melissa Benoist, 36

Kara Danvers

1

Tyler Hoechlin, 37

Superman

2

Grant Gustin, 34

Barry Allen / The Flash

3

Katie McGrath, 41

Lena Luthor

4

Chris Wood, 36

Mon-El

5

Chyler Leigh, 42

Alex Danvers

6

Emma Tremblay, 20

Ruby Arias

7

Stephen Amell, 43

Oliver Queen / Green Arrow

8

Darren Criss, 37

Music Meister

9

Jenna Dewan, 43

Lucy Lane

10

Jon Cryer, 59

Lex Luther

11

Jeremy Jordan, 39

Winn Schott

12